Its now legitimate to scream Go on, son! at random intervals during the day. Although that said, I do agree with your overall point. I understand you were on The Daily Show and you make light of certain situations. @DgGentle: I was going to watch the Palace v West Ham game but I cant listen to another 90 mins of Karen Carney so Newcastle v Leeds it is. She has been commentating since 2007. There werent women doing football analysis, Sanderson says. Indy, October 24, 2019 in Main Discussion - Norwich City. To counter-balance, I wouldn't mind Joe Brand commentating on the next England game. NFL College Football NBA MLB World Baseball Classic USFL FIFA Women's World Cup. Presenters, yes, great. Read Also: Champions League Winning Managers who got hired mid-season, Best Female Football Commentators (continued), After her retirement, Karen Julia Carney became a football journalist and commentator for Sky Sports and Amazon Prime. I found it a tough listen if I'm honest,' he said. Gruden can kick rocks, but we weren't fans well before this whole mess. Powered by Invision Community. There is no way of arguing that two women should not be on our screens during the mens World Cup, without also arguing their gender makes them innately worse at the job. Wed 24 Oct 2012 06.58 EDT. Some appeal, some less so. Difference there is good commentary is key to watching the game on tv. A weekly round-up of some of the best articles featured in the most recent issue of the New Statesman, sent each Saturday. You still might get a slap even though youre a woman. She played college Football for the University of Notre Dame. For 90 minutes I would prefer to hear a male voice. Most US English commentators are rubbish. So much about Football, informative and valuable. There's enough men making a living talking bolox about the game, women should commentate on their own sport. Gruden paired with Mike Tirico on MNF for several years after ESPN got the rights. With 260 goals, who is the Premier League's all-time top scorer? The rest of the guff about sexism is irrelevant, and very tedious. Heather Ann O'Reilly is one of the best female football commentators. The female commentators in this years mens World Cup Eni Aluko and Alex Scott have done an outstanding job of navigating the patronising minefield of the punditry box. LEAD COLLEGE FOOTBALL & BASKETBALL PLAY-BY-PLAY ANNOUNCER. However, I do understand and partially agree that there is reason to believe positive discrimination has led to female commentators getting to commentate on big matches before theyve really proven themselves elsewhere. Both pioneers in their field and experienced football players, Aluko and Scott have had to prove themselves beyond expectations, rewarded only with thepatronising surprise of a male colleague, orhaving their analysis literally repeated back to themby the Phil Neville. Many football fans are thrilled with Scotts in-depth analysis during commentary. Ferguson worked as a studio commentator for ESPN. The commentator said he understood why former Chelsea player Jason Cundy complained about Vicki Sparks commentating for the BBC at the World Cup. Published: 09:51 GMT, 25 June 2018 | Updated: 09:25 GMT, 26 June 2018. Copyright Archant Community Media Limited Lyndsey explained that young girls who were football fans now had 'someone to relate to'. This doesn't seem to work so well in football, but are we talking commentary or punditry here? By and large in football coverage the commentators are not ex-players, but they have the pundits who are. Skincare for your hair How to trick yourself slim: Top nutritionist reveals her tips including shrinking your cutlery, sniffing Head over heels for Kate! Beth Mowins, the first woman to call a game on "Monday Night Football," sitting with Rex Ryan, her broadcast partner . With regards to women, I don't agree they are any worse or better than men. Read Also: The Best Referees in The Premier League History. Heather Ann OReilly is one of the best female football commentators. Even at the highest level, women have their fair share of difficulties. Beaming Princess of Wales watches a young boy backflip during St David's Day Lovely in lilac! Charlotte Wilder. Required fields are marked *. Ranking: 10 Best Chelsea Players of All Time, The Evolution of Chelsea FC under Roman Abramovich. Jon Gruden This has nothing to do with the horrendous emails that were uncovered that led to the former Las Vegas Raiders coach resigning. Support 100 years of independent journalism. I hope this is /s. Leslie Marie Osborne is one of the few women football commentators. Doug McIntyre. She joinsGary Lineker, Frank Lampard, Rio Ferdinand and Alan Shearer on the BBC panel this month. When I was younger I didnt see a Karen Carney on the TV or a Sue Smith. I can identify with it. Diversity on a panel is simply the result of equality of opportunity. Michael Owen sends me to sleep and Mark Lawrenson just shrugs and grunts. Sue Smith was the first woman pundit to speak about the mens game on the BBCs Final Score and Skys Soccer Saturday and she has seen dramatic changes since she began her media career over a decade ago. Your email address will not be published. A former broadcast assistant for Radio Newcastle, she led the BBC's coverage of the Portugal vs Morocco match on June 20. It can be expressed more eloquently perhaps by saying that you agree with equality of opportunity but not equality of outcome. Suddenly, a sport that hasritualistically excluded usbecomes all-consuming, sneaking its way into every crevice of mainstream culture. 'This is not a hill you want to die on, that women have annoying squeaky voices, when you yourself have an annoying squeaky voice. and our Happens in a lot of other sports now - liked the dart lady a few weeks ago. Maybe the person that picked her also picked the lass on BT who in her expert opinion expected more from McBurnie after his 20+total last season helped fire us to promotion, but of course in this PC world, none of the other pundits dare correct her. The temperature under my collar has been known to rise on occasions and I have even once turned the sound down to avoid the 'screecher' recently employed by Channel Four. They just looked down and shuffled their feet. NFL WRITER. I'm no fan of the female commentator in the game thus far. I just want to go and do my job, Smith tells i. When it gets exciting, and her tone also goes up its actually uncomfortable to listen to. Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group, PrettyLittleThing - Offers on women's clothing, Get inspired by the newest styles and offers, Click through for ASOS promo codes this Autumn, Spend less with Missguided's exclusive codes, Treat yourself to offers on make-up and accessories, Check out the latest Wayfair sale to save on furniture. It's simply a matter of how good they are and there are many factors to this ranging from John Motson's Encyclopedia Britannica-style approach to Brian Moore's cool analytical and almost personal approach. If I get one name wrong, I know its going to be trending onTwitter., Smith says the negativity she receives is usually related to her gender, and often references the kitchen. Mowins is one of the industry's relatively few female sports announcers and has amassed a considerable sum. The one employed by Sky during the Ashes (name alludes me) wasn't so bad, but I often thought that she brought little more insight to the table than I could have done, and I play pub cricket. Consequently the s-exof the commentator is probably irrelevant. Hardly ever adds useful insight. Less than a decade ago, the question of whether a woman might ever be a pundit for a major mens international football tournament was mostly posed as a hypothetical. OReilly played for the United States womens national soccer team (USWNT), with whom she won three Olympic gold medals and a FIFA Womens World Cup. Shes one of the few that has the temerity to actually talk about football tactics during a football match instead of just harping on performance. He brown tongues everyone and everything and tries to tell us what we should think. @FearonNiks: Karen Carney is a SHAMBOLIC commentator, and it has nothing to do with her being female!!! what is it with BT SPORT and employing shocking commentators! Chelsea star Jason Cundy said he found the BBC's coverage of the World Cupclash between Morocco and Portugal - the first to be led by a woman - a 'tough listen' during a heated debate on GMB on Monday. I do like Michelle Owen, she actually sounds like she knows what shes talking about and talks like a fan. She typically calls women's college sports, and became the second woman to call nationally televised college football games for ESPN in 2005. Leslie Osborne Leslie Marie Osborne is one of the few women football commentators. Emma Hayes: In praise of the best pundit at the Euros and what makes the ITV co-commentator so good. Hes a shit commentator and a shit pundit. Women In Football, which promotes female representation in the sport, hailed her as a "history maker". It was another matchday which saw Twitter users take to say how unbearable she is, with @Gallagherlad95 writing: Said it the other day, but Alex Scott has been a credit to females in punditry. Theres a few male commentators just as bad! BBC legend Barry Davies says men find female football commentators tough to listen to because their voices get too squeaky. 2021 Associated Newspapers Limited. Sorry ladies! Robyn Cowen has a voice like nails down a window. Gonzlez Canales is an American-born Mexican football commentator and former player. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. You love to see it Go Cry Jeff FOH," he tweeted. I did but its dull watching the game in silence. Most US English commentators are rubbish. Your colleagues keep making you donate 3 to a plastic bag of lost hopes in exchange for a sad, paper flag of Morocco. But what message does it send to the millions of female football fans when the commentary and punditry is exclusively male? Dr Stacey Pope, an associate professor at the Department of Sport and Exercise Sciences at Durham University, says the backlash to more women analysing football on screen can be linked to a revolution within football which occurred after tapes were leaked of Andy Gray and Richard Keys making sexist comments about assistant referee Sian Massey in2011. Three players share the record for most Premier League red cards (8). This isnt sexism did you spot that first paragraph about how great Aluko is? But now you see people like myself and kids believe they can be you, It gives people a chance to realise they can do it.. All rights reserved. In 2014, Eni Aluko became Match of the Day's first female pundit; in 2018 Vicky Sparks became the first woman to commentate on a World Cup match on British television and in the same year, Alex . Now you see what we see. Press J to jump to the feed. So, well let you some of the best female football commentators. Here is the list of the 20 worst announcers in sports. JavaScript is disabled. It would seem her skills as a pundit and reporter hasnt gone down too well again with many stating they just cant watch the match with the sound on because of her. Sparks - who according to her Twitter profile loves 'God, sport and life' - has broadcasting experience with the BBC's Final Score and Radio 5 Live. Viza has in-depth knowledge of Spanish Womens Football. Karen Carney has been the total opposite.. So, it is easier for male ex-footballers to retire and get famous as a fotball commentator. Just awful. what is it with BT SPORT and employing shocking commentators! David Moyes threatens to slap the BBC's Vicki Sparks. Dennis Miller 1 of 20 One morning, ABC executives woke up with the bright idea to put Dennis Miller on Monday Night Football.. Like with everything else in life, I think that if a person is good enough they should be given a chance, male, female or any of the other new gender alternatives but deary me. But Vicki's performance was blasted on Twitter. @MurrayyyDaniel: The second half possession stats just came up and we (Newcastle) had 43% and Steve Mcmanaman used that to suggest were now a great attacking force, @charlie__mellor: I beg you add an option to mute Steve McManaman @btsportfootball, @Lee18_92Johnson: Hendrick has done well second half This is more like it exciting #nufc, @Alex_Full16: There absolutely has to be a way to mute just Steve McManaman, my god. Im not asking to be on the TV because Im black or because Im gay or because Im a woman, Sanderson says. Jacqui Oatley shouting what a strike does my head in though. She presents and commentates for the BBC, Five Live and ESPN . What's your biggest turn off? 00:00. Copyright 2022 Fan Banterwww.fanbanter.co.uk by Digital Unicorn, Andrea Radrizzani hit back at what she said, Jurgen Klopp slammed by fans for his excuse to Liverpools goalless draw at Crystal Palace, Latest Premier League TV selections confirmed for April and May, Gabby Agbonlahor claims Casemiro should be arrested as new video of incident surfaces, Frank Lampards incredible list of fines imposed at Chelsea, Ex-Arsenal and Bradford player handed three and a half year prison sentence, The viral leaked photo Jack Grealish wont want you to see, Arsenals William Saliba goes viral with explicit leaked video, X-rated James Rodriguez WhatsApp photo goes viral, Mark Lawrensons last ever Premier League score predictions. CBS ESPN Fox NBC NFL Originals By Joe Lucia on 11/16/2020 The 2020 NFL announcer rankings have landed, and here are some quick notes before we get into the nitty gritty. After her retirement, though, shed taken up many roles in football and one of them is commentating. No my tittle backs my point, dont just give the job toKaren because its the PCequality thing to do! Womens football is a very different game from that played at the [mens] World Cup, writes Kelner, who does not play this mythical sport known as womens football. Viewers let rip at Karen Carney once again as she makes yet another blunder which many a football fan pointed out on Twitter. @fullback03: Karen Carney just about to congratulate West Ham on getting through to the next round. But when youre a woman, you have to research more. So so SOOO sick of idiot women commentators in sport! Eni Aluko was absolute garbage during the World Cup, particularly when compared with Scott. ', Controversial:Ex-footballer Jason Cundy claimed that female football commentators voices are too 'high-pitched' during a discussion on GMB on Monday morning, Sports broadcaster Lyndsey Hooper (right) disagreed with Jason's views and said there should be more women for young girls to relate to, GMB host Piers Morgan said that Jason was being 'ridiculous' and branded him a 'sexist pig' over his comments, Turning to the former Chelsea footballer, he added: 'Actually my only criteria Jason, is not that they are male or female, [it] is, "do they know what they are talking about? Nobody has said it is sexist. Vicki Sparks, 29, made history last week when she became the first woman to lead live coverage of a World Cup football match on British TV, keeping fans up to speed from Moscows Luzhniki Stadium. @FplPhantom: Is there actually anyone worse to listen to for 90 minutes than Karen Carney on @btsportfootball absolute nonsense just falls out her mouth. Graham Potter is just the fall guy for Todd Boehly's aimless Chelsea plan, Casemiros hunger makes him Man Utds biggest culture changer since Eric Cantona, Man City plan Etihad extension to overtake Arsenal's Emirates in stadium size, How Roma revived 'emotional, not crazy' Jose Mourinho with an HR guru and smart signings, Ex-Chelsea bidder Stephen Pagliuca says he would have run the club in the same way as Boehly, Wakefield's next Super League match under threat with new pitch set for re-inspection, How to watch F1 2023: TV channel, live stream details and full schedule, Why Arsenal and Liverpool's games aren't on TV tonight, Liverpool's data shows 'we are not as bad as everyone says we are', says club research director, English football is failing its 'duty of care' to players like Ivan Toney over gambling rules, Wakefield Trinity vs Huddersfield Giants is on after controversial pitch passes inspection, Ben Stokes 'not jeopardising' Ashes chances by playing IPL, insists Brendon McCullum, Marcus Smith's days as England's No 1 fly-half look over after squad axe and Ford's return, Survive with bat and 'massive mental game' with ball - how Australia can reverse India disaster, Do not sell or share my personal information. While women have broken into the industry through sideline reporting and analyst positionsJessica Mendoza in MLB and Doris Burke for the NBA are two high-profile recent examplesthe play-by-play. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Furthermore, she is a former member of the United States womens national soccer team and previously played for FC Gold Pride and the Boston Breakers in the WPS. But Vicki Sparks and Robyn Cowans and the lesbian haircut that is Aleidh Barbour, just pss off!! Lets ask Karen Carney pic.twitter.com/wpOCSR2waz, Alistair Skeet (@marbleally) January 24, 2021. That doesn't happen me as my wife like to ask daft questions during the game. And I think your football career probably sets you up for that you get used to getting that constructive criticism. The inclusion of professional footballers Eni Aluko and Alex Scott to this years punditry has been likened togetting a netball player to discuss basketball. Watching the match was former England captain John Terry, who told his Instagram followers that he was 'having to watch this game with no volume'. There are many great women involved In football today such as my friends Jacqueline Gold and Karren Brady and I hope we see more women involved in football. As TVB said the OP could have made his point better and the thread title is misleading. Davies, 80, said: Theyre a tough listen because we havent heard them in the past. Plaintiff Victoria Russell, a former NFL Films HR employee, claims she saw categories in their system that included cheerleader buttocks, cheerleaders rear end, close up of cheerleaders breasts; cleavage shot, random woman, cleavage shot, and more. Its simply impossible to enjoy a game that shes commenting on. Sparks is the first woman to commentate live on a World Cup game for British TV. One viewer @tony_passmore wrote: Nothing to do with our Covid promotion comments but Karen Carneys voice is like chalk down a blackboard. The comments below have not been moderated. @MissVJFxx: I think everyone who gave #lufc and us fans shit for calling out Karen Carney owes us an apology. Both pioneers in their field and experienced football players, Aluko and Scott have had to prove themselves beyond expectations, rewarded only with the patronising . 00:17. Its sad that was the first time thats ever happened, but I thought Id tweet about it because it is a positive thing., Both Sanderson and Smith express frustration at the idea that women pundits are a tick box exercise for broadcasters, a criticism they both receive regularly. Danielle Victoria Slaton is currently a soccer analyst and commentator for the San Jose Earthquakes, Fox Sports, and the Pac-12 Network. Thank you, thats my point, as I said theres a lot of superbly talented lady pundits who are great on tv and commentary, but its hard to listen to poor commentators who ruin the pleasure of watching the game through just talking for the sake of it! Apple 'Ted Lasso' S3 trailer sets up a crucial Ted-Nate clash "Things seem to be falling apart both on and off the pitch, but Team Lasso is set to give it their best . If shes not good at commentary then thats not her fault but the fault of BT. After the tournament, she earned a lot of positive reviews that helped and propelled her to further success. I hate her as well - cr? That or they had to turn over. Footy Accumulators (@FootyAccums) January 26, 2021, Christ Steve McManaman commentating on one game, Karen Carney on the other, BT really scraping the bottom of the barrel here, Luke Wallace (@Luke2Wallace) January 26, 2021. The Sun website is regulated by the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO), Our journalists strive for accuracy but on occasion we make mistakes. It seems to say. Its getting to the stage that fans are now taking to BT Sports social media pages to ask for her to be replaced. The 5 Worst NFL Broadcasters Ever, Ranked 5. Now dont get me wrong some great female reporters, Kelly Cates, Gabby Logan, Laura Woods and Bianca Westwood to name a few, but watching Arsenal, i assume itsKarren Carey commentating tonight but her andAlex Scott do my head in, just talking for the sake of talking making not much contribution to the game! In 2017, Beth became the first woman in 30 years to call a National Football League game. She could take the most exciting game and make it sound dull as dishwater. Tracey Cox asks men the Hannah Betts' Better not younger: Secret to longer, thicker locks? Who are they? A weekly newsletter helping you fit together the pieces of the global economic slowdown. Pam Ward has long been a subject of ridicule for her play-by-play announcing of NCAA football and with good reason. Surely it should be about quality in the job and not just to make sure you comply with the PC requirements? Never forget his meltdown over goal line technology during the 2014 WC. ', Outrage: Cundy's comments have sparked a backlash on Twitter, with presenter Jacqui Oatley and footballer Fran Kirby tweeting their disappointment. Some people think its a weakness to show that it impacts you but something has to be done. ', Piers hit back: 'I think some of the women have been better than the men and I have been very pleasantly surprised that this World Cup has a lot more female voices. @leondepreli_: Karen Carney is an awful commentator. Scurry was the starting goalkeeper for the United States womens national soccer team at the 1995 World Cup and 1996 Summer Olympics. Cundy's comments have similarly sparked outrage on Twitter, with sports presenter Jacqui Oatley - the first woman to commentate on Match of the Day - blasting the ex-footballer. Queen Letizia of Spain cut an elegant figure in a matching pink skirt and top as she Do not sell or share my personal information. The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline. Fuck me their all prolifically SHIT!!! Discussing the idea, BBC broadcasters at the 2014 World Cup noted that they wanted pundits who had experience in the mens sport. However, there are a few female commentators in the game. Makes me smile when people get all sensitive about this and say its sexist, turn on sky sports news and try to convince me that most of those girls looks didnt play a part in them getting the job. I read this sort of stuff and then it becomes no surprise to me that Oxford University has banned clapping so people don't get triggered. During her playing days, she played as a winger and midfielder. ', Earlier this week, BBC presenter Dan Walker praised the performance of Miss Sparks on her debut with the words: 'Well played Vicki Sparks. Top Shows. Georges was part of an all-conquering Lyon side and also represented PSG prior to retiring in 2018. And see an English team win it!'. Alex Scott is a talented broadcaster, not a token diversity hire she deserves the Football Focus gig. Unfortunately for Kelner, his rhetoric cant save him here. Love, LUFC. 0. The article hides its misogyny behind arguments sold as watertight logic. Susanna tried to draw the heated debate to a close, remarking: 'God forbid a woman could talk for ninety minutes it's something I can only dream of.'. Davies, famed for brilliant commentary moments such as Just look at his face!, said: Everything is in a hurry in the present generation. In addition, she is a World Cup champion and a two-time Olympic gold medalist. That wealth of experience is both vital and entertaining. Kelly Jayne Smith is an English former football forward who spent three spells with Arsenal Ladies and broke records with Seton Hall University then played professionally with the Womens United Soccer Association (WUSA) franchise Philadelphia Charge. Scott, who earned over 100 England caps, will also become the first woman to host the BBCs Football Focus. Let me know what you guys think tho but either way fuck Robbie savage. The female commentators in this year's men's World Cup Eni Aluko and Alex Scott have done an outstanding job of navigating the patronising minefield of the punditry box. Although she can be controversial as a pundit, fans no doubt love her commentaries. The former England player says she felt prepared for negativity, but one vicious Twitter pile-on made her question her choices. The Best Midfielders In The Premier League History, The Premier League Top Scorer Prediction For The 2021/22 Season, Best American Soccer Players to Play in the Premier League, Goalkeepers Who Scored In The English Premier League, Ranking: The 10 Best Manchester City Players of All Time, 10 Greatest Liverpool Players of All Time, Worst Arsenal Signings: The Top 10 Biggest Arsenal Flops. Hardly ever adds useful insight. To widen the discussion tocricket I feel that it is a different matter. We and our partners share information on your use of this website to help improve your experience. Carney has a vast knowledge of the Womens Super League and mens Premier League. Many of her mistakes were highlighted with viewers losing patience with her commentating on games. The Whites brutally mocked her on social media, with owner Andrea Radrizzani getting involved, as footage was shared of Carneys analysis of Leeds style following their 5-0 victory against West Brom at the Hawthorns last month.